Cats Cradle
Bokonism tries to solve the issue of violent dogmatism by making the whole religion playful. Nothing in the religion is holy as they say in one point in the novel not even God. You cannot take anything too seriously or you miss the whole point of Bokonism. What would they have to be driven about? The whole religion is one great big play. Everyone is having too much fun being playful to take the idea of religion serious.
Spark notes took a different approach to the question then I did. They pondered what drives a person to do violent dogmatic acts. I questioned what a person would have to be dogmatic about. Their approach focuses on the lies that Bokonism is built upon while mine focuses on the tone of the religion.
Felix mocks the idea of evil through his perception of the world. Evil is a subjective idea and Felix has no idea what the word means. He remarks “What is sin?” While this could be read as being simple ignorance it is also a deep question, pondering the nature of evil. One could think Felix an evil mad scientist creating both the atom bomb and ice-nine. The only problem with this perception is that Felix has no malicious intent with these ideas. He is simply indifferent to anything outside of his vision and neglects to take the holistic view of things. He represents unfettered uncaring science which is an ideal many hold but his character shows how such an ideal would not necessarily be what people are hoping for. Instead of inventing things to help mankind Felix is more fascinated by those that can end it. His apathy is the true evil in the novel.
The spark notes answer takes an interesting approach in thinking of not necessarily evil people but in terms of maturity level. The source of destruction falls not into evil hands but rather ignorant hand, those unable to comprehend what they hold.
Dr. Breed’s commencement speech is ironic for many reasons. The first is that he says that science will solve all problems. This is very ironic because science has just created the atomic bomb the largest source of destruction known to man. Dr. Breed claims that science is solving problems and it is in a sense. The bomb ends the war by causing so much devastation the other side doesn’t want to fight anymore. It’s solving problems but not in the way that people think about solving problems. He is not curing diseases he’s making weapons of war, promoting conflict. The other ironic thing is that he claims science will find the secret of life. It turns out that they have but neither the hooker nor the barkeep can remember. The concept which seems so vital to science means nothing to common people. This secret which seems so vital means nothing to most people. Life exists does it matter why it does?
The spark notes answer neglects to mention the irony in Dr. Breed’s claim that science will solve problems. It does however mention that the reason the secret of life doesn’t matter to most people is that there is no self gratification.
The difference between Julian and Bokonon’s lifestyle is in how they are trying to help people. Bokonon is trying to help people psychologically. He is a believer in mind over matter, that people’s beliefs can transcend their circumstances. Julian Castle however is trying to physically go out and help people. Bokonon doesn’t have the resources that Castle does to go out and help people. Castle spends his day in a hospital helping care for the bodies of the people of San Larenzo. Bokonon is hiding in the forest helping care for the minds of the people of the island.
